Off-Broadway promotional poster
by Daniel Waters
|Productions||2010 New York Concert|
2013 Los Angeles
2015 San Francisco
2018 Off West End
2018 West End
Heathers: The Musical is a rock musical with music, lyrics and book by Laurence O'Keefe and Kevin Murphy, based on the 1988 film of the same name written by Daniel Waters. After a sold-out Los Angeles tryout, the show moved Off-Broadway in 2014. After the run in 2014 the show had an Off-West End run in 2018 and then transferred to the West End in 2018 for a limited engagement.
In 1989, 17-year-old Veronica Sawyer despairs at Westerburg High School's hellish social hierarchy, where students like Martha Dunnstock are tormented by jocks Ram Sweeney and Kurt Kelly, and the school is ruled by the Heathers: weak-willed Heather McNamara, bulimic Heather Duke, and "mythic bitch" queen Heather Chandler. When Veronica's talent for forgery gets the Heathers out of detention, they give her a makeover and elevate her to their inner circle ("Beautiful").
Chandler discovers Martha's crush on Ram, and orders Veronica to forge a love letter from him to Martha, tempting Veronica with the promise of popularity ("Candy Store"). The mysterious, Baudelaire-quoting new kid, Jason "J.D." Dean, criticizes Veronica for betraying her friend. J.D. wins a fight against the jocks, and Veronica finds herself unexpectedly attracted ("Fight for Me"). Veronica's parents confess to Veronica that they aren't sure they like their daughter's new friends and would prefer if she was friends with Martha again. ("Candy Store (Playoff)").
Veronica flirts with J.D. at a 7-Eleven, and he extols the virtues of the Slurpee for numbing his grief ("Freeze Your Brain"). At Ram's homecoming party, Veronica gets increasingly drunk and high ("Big Fun"). When the Heathers cruelly prank Martha, Veronica angrily resigns from the clique and vomits on Chandler's shoes. Her reputation in ruins, Veronica breaks into J.D.'s bedroom and loses her virginity to him ("Dead Girl Walking").
After tormented dreams ("Veronica's Chandler Nightmare"), Veronica, with J.D. in tow, apologizes to Chandler. Veronica and J.D. mix hangover cures for Chandler; J.D. adds toxic drain cleaner to his mug as a joke, but the mugs get accidentally switched. Chandler drinks from the poisoned mug and dies. Veronica panics, but J.D. convinces her to forge a suicide note, which paints a more complex, misunderstood Heather. This fictionalized Chandler wins the school's sympathy and is even more worshipped in death than she was in life ("The Me Inside Of Me").
Veronica tries to get on with her normal life but is berated and mocked by Chandler's ghost. Veronica tries to rescue the Heathers from a drunk Kurt and Ram, who aggressively beg her for sex, but she gives them more alcohol until they pass out ("Blue", in the alternate song, "You're Welcome," she escapes by pushing them into a cow pasture full of manure). Heather Duke assumes Chandler's status and symbolic red scrunchie, and Ram and Kurt tell everyone they had sex with Veronica ("Blue (Reprise)" in the Off-Broadway production. "Never Shut Up Again", replacing it in the West End version). Veronica is branded a slut ("Blue (Playoff)", not included in the West End or high-school version), and when J.D. attacks the jocks to defend her, they savagely beat him.
J.D. and Veronica comfort each other and plan a vengeful prank: Veronica will lure the jocks to the cemetery with the promise of making their fictional threesome real, then J.D. and Veronica will shoot them with tranquilizer "Ich Lüge" bullets to knock them out, leaving a forged suicide note confessing they were gay lovers. When the jocks arrive, J.D. shoots Ram but Veronica misses Kurt. As she realizes Ram is dead and the bullets are real, J.D. shoots Kurt dead and proclaims his undying love to a horrified Veronica ("Our Love Is God").
At Ram and Kurt's funeral, a distraught Veronica reflects that they could have outgrown their immaturity ("Prom or Hell?"). Grief-stricken, Ram's Dad chastises Kurt's Dad for remaining homophobic, until Kurt's Dad suddenly kisses Ram's Dad -- revealing their own secret love affair. Confession brings catharsis and all vow to make the world a more tolerant place ("My Dead Gay Son"). Convinced the murders are for the greater good, J.D. urges Veronica to target Heather Duke next. She refuses, and as J.D. complains about doing nothing in the face of injustice, he reveals he witnessed his mother's suicide. Veronica gives him an ultimatum: give up violence and live a normal life with her, or lose her forever ("Seventeen"). J.D. agrees and they reconcile. Martha tells Veronica she suspects J.D. of murdering the jocks, believing Ram's "love note" is proof. Veronica, urged on by Chandler's ghost, confesses that she forged the note to humiliate Martha, who runs off in tears.
Guidance counsellor Mrs. Fleming holds a televised therapy assembly ("Shine a Light"). She urges everyone to reveal their fears and insecurities, but only Heather McNamara admits to suicidal thoughts ("Lifeboat"), and Duke mocks her and whips the students into a frenzy ("Shine a Light (Reprise)"). Veronica lashes out and blurts a confession - "they didn't kill themselves! I killed them!" -- but everyone laughs mockingly, thinking Veronica is only desperate for attention. Shortly after, Veronica stops McNamara from overdosing in the bathroom. J.D., carrying a gun, again tries to persuade Veronica to kill Duke; realising how unstable he is, Veronica breaks up with him (In the Off-Broadway production, there is not a song used for Veronica having enough of J.D.'s unstable nature, however, "I Say No" is a song made exclusively for the West End production that explains everything through song). She storms out as the students organise a pep rally ("Heyo, Westerburg").
J.D. blackmails Duke into making the student body sign a petition. Martha, mourning Ram, jumps off a bridge ("Kindergarten Boyfriend") but survives. Veronica rushes to the hospital, taunted by the ghosts of Kurt, Ram, and Chandler ("Yo Girl"). She returns home, where J.D. breaks in. As she barricades herself in the closet, he reveals the petition, signed by every student, is actually a mass suicide note - his plan to blow up the pep rally will look like a mass suicide. He breaks open the closet to find Veronica dangling from a noose. Grief-stricken, he leaves to complete his plan ("Meant to Be Yours").
Veronica, having faked her suicide, races to stop J.D. ("Dead Girl Walking (Reprise)") She confronts him in the boiler room; in their struggle, J.D. is shot. Unable to disarm the bomb, Veronica takes it to the empty football field. J.D. convinces her to let him take the bomb instead ("I Am Damaged"); it explodes, killing him alone.
Returning to school, Veronica takes the scrunchie from Heather Duke and ends the era of social ridicule. Veronica invites Martha and Heather McNamara to hang out, rent a movie, and be kids before childhood is over ("Seventeen (Reprise)").
+ Not featured on the World Premiere Cast Recording.
++ Songs added to the West End version and all future productions.
"You're Welcome" replaces "Blue," a song on the World Premiere Cast Recording. "You're Welcome" was originally written by O'Keefe and Murphy for the High School edition but was added to the official show beginning with the 2018 London production. O'Keefe and Murphy preferred "You're Welcome" as they had come to feel that "Blue" was a bit lazy, and had inadvertently trivialized the lead character's fears (given that Veronica is cornered by two drunk, entitled high school football stars who refused to hear the word "no"). While "Blue" contained no dialogue for Veronica, by contrast "You're Welcome" allows Veronica to express her fears and solve her problem, defeating her assailants decisively. As well as providing a more empowering alternative for Veronica, the new song remedies the way that "Blue" was often considered as "treating date rape as a laughing matter" and presenting sexual assault or harassment as "boyish antics", due to the comical nature of the song. A new song for Heather Duke, "Never Shut Up Again", was also added for the London run, replacing "Blue (Reprise)". For the 2017 workshop, there was a different song to replace "Blue (Reprise)", which became "Big Fun (Reprise)", part of which is now included in "Never Shut Up Again". In the last week at The Other Palace, the authors added a new song after "Shine a Light (Reprise)" called "I Say No", in which Veronica finally dumps JD when he proposes a return to murdering, telling him "you need help I can't provide" and walking out on him. The song remained in the show for the Haymarket run and was released on February 15, 2019, as the first single on the West End cast album.
The show's director, Andy Fickman, had been working with Daniel Waters (the screenwriter of the film) on the musical. After seeing Laurence O'Keefe's work with Legally Blonde and how he transitioned film to theatre, he decided to pair him with Reefer Madness collaborator Kevin Murphy. Fickman said of the experience, "we found that Heathers gave a great deal of opportunity for '80s commentary and a great chance for music and storytelling".
Three private readings of the work in progress were held in Los Angeles in 2009, each starring Kristen Bell as Veronica. The first was in March at the Beverly Hills offices of Endeavor Agency (starring Christian Campbell as J.D.); the second in June at the Hudson Theatre on Santa Monica Boulevard (starring Scott Porter as J.D.); and the third in December at the Coast Theatre in West Hollywood, starring James Snyder as J.D. In each reading, Jenna Leigh Green, Corri English, and Christine Lakin played Heather Chandler, Heather McNamara and Heather Duke respectively. 
On September 13-14, 2010, Heathers was presented as a concert at Joe's Pub. The show was directed by Andy Fickman, and it starred Annaleigh Ashford as Veronica Sawyer, Jeremy Jordan as Jason Dean, Jenna Leigh Green as Heather Chandler, Corri English as Heather McNamara, and Christine Lakin as Heather Duke, James Snyder as Kurt Kelly, PJ Griffith as Ram Sweeney, Julie Garnyé as Martha "Dumptruck" Dunnstock, Eric Leviton as Ram's Dad, Kevin Pariseau as Kurt's Dad/Principal, Jill Abramovitz as Ms. Fleming/Veronica's Mom, Tom Compton as Hipster Dork/Preppy Kid, Alex Ellis as Goth Girl/English Teacher/Young Republicanette, and Kelly Karbacz as Stoner Chick/School Psychologist.
The show played at the Hudson Backstage Theatre in Los Angeles for a limited engagement on the weekends from September 21, 2013 to October 6, 2013. The cast included Barrett Wilbert Weed as Veronica, Ryan McCartan as J.D., Sarah Halford as Heather Chandler, Kristolyn Lloyd as Heather Duke, and Elle McLemore as Heather McNamara. McLemore was the only Heather to remain with the cast when the show transferred to Off-Broadway, but after Alice Lee left the production, Kristolyn Lloyd reprised her role as Heather Duke.
In 2013, it was announced that Heathers: The Musical would be brought to Off-Broadway, previews beginning in March at New World Stages, directed by Andy Fickman. Coincidentally, New World is also the name of the original film's distributor. In February 2014, the cast was announced, including Barrett Wilbert Weed, Ryan McCartan, and Elle McLemore reprising their roles as Veronica, J.D., and Heather McNamara, respectively, with new additions to the cast being Jessica Keenan Wynn as Heather Chandler, Alice Lee as Heather Duke and Tony Award winner Anthony Crivello as Bill Sweeney/'Big Bud' Dean. The show began previews on March 15, 2014, and opened on March 31, 2014.
A cast album was recorded on April 15-16, 2014 with an in-store and digital release of June 17, 2014. It was released a week early on June 10, 2014.
Following the workshop, the musical had its official London premiere in the Theatre at The Other Palace, London from June 9 to August 4, 2018, starring Carrie Hope Fletcher as Veronica Sawyer, Jamie Muscato as J.D., Dominic Anderson as Ram Sweeney, Edward Baruwa as Ram's Dad, and Jon Boydon as Kurt's Dad. The production is produced by Bill Kenwright and Paul Taylor-Mills, directed again by Andy Fickman and with choreographer/associate director Gary Lloyd. For the London production "Blue" has been changed to the new song "You're Welcome" and Heather Duke has received her own song "Never Shut Up Again" as well as a few script changes.
Heathers transferred to the West End at the Theatre Royal Haymarket, running from September 3, 2018 to November 24, 2018. A new song for Veronica, "I Say No," as well as a few script changes to Act 2 were added for the transfer.
A West End cast recording was released on Ghostlight Records on March 1. The album premiered at #1 on the iTunes UK Soundtracks Charts and at #2 on the iTunes UK Album charts. The album premiered at #24 on the Official Albums Chart.
The Australian premiere of Heathers: The Musical at the Hayes Theatre in Sydney was staged in July-August 2015. Directed by Trevor Ashley with choreography by Cameron Mitchell, it starred Jaz Flowers as Veronica Sawyer, Stephen Madsen as J.D., Lucy Maunder as Heather Chandler, Erin Clare as Heather McNamara, and Libby Asciak as Heather Duke. The well-received production transferred the following year, with mostly the same cast, for seasons in Brisbane (Playhouse, Queensland Performing Arts Centre) in January 2016, Melbourne (Playhouse, Arts Centre Melbourne) in May 2016, and the Sydney Opera House's Playhouse in June 2016.
|Original Off-West End
|Original West End|
|Veronica Sawyer||Annaleigh Ashford||Barrett Wilbert Weed||Jaz Flowers||Carrie Hope Fletcher|
|Jason "J.D." Dean||Jeremy Jordan||Ryan McCartan||Stephen Madsen||Jamie Muscato|
|Heather Chandler||Jenna Leigh Green||Sarah Halford||Jessica Keenan Wynn||Lucy Maunder||Jodie Steele|
|Heather McNamara||Corri English||Elle McLemore||Erin Clare||Sophie Isaacs|
|Heather Duke||Christine Lakin||Kristolyn Lloyd||Alice Lee||Libby Asciak||T'Shan Williams|
|Martha Dunnstock||Julie Garnye||Katie Ladner||Lauren McKenna||Jenny O'Leary|
|Ram Sweeney||PJ Griffith||Jon Eidson||Jakob Ambrose||Dominic Andersen|
|Kurt Kelly||James Snyder||Evan Todd||Vincent Hooper||Chris Chung|
|Bill Sweeney / Big Bud Dean / Coach Ripper||Eric Leviton||Rex Smith||Anthony Crivello||N/A||Edward Baruwa||Nathan Amzi|
|Paul Kelly / Mr. Sawyer / Principal Gowan||Zachary Ford||Daniel Cooney||N/A||Jon Boydon|
|Mrs. Sawyer / Pauline Fleming||Jill Abramovitz||Rena Strober||Michelle Duffy||Lauren McKenna||Rebecca Lock|
|Stoner Chick||N/A||Rachel Flynn||Sage Douglas [a]||Charlotte Jaconelli|
|New Wave Girl||Alex Ellis||Charissa Hogeland||Michelle Barr||Lauren Drew|
|Young Republicanette||N/A||Cait Fairbanks||N/A||Olivia Moore|
|Beleaguered Geek||Tom Compton||Zach Bandler||Dustin Sullivan||Rebecca Hetherington||Alex James-Hatton [b]|
|Preppy Stud / Officer Milner||N/A||AJ Meijer||N/A||Sergio Pasquariello||Brandon Lee Sears|
|Hipster Dork / Officer McCord||N/A||Trevor Shor||Dan Domenech||Leigh Sleightholme||N/A||John Lumsden|
|Drama Club Drama Queen||N/A||N/A||N/A||N/A||N/A||Merryl Ansah|
Heathers: The Musical's 2014 Off-Broadway run was generally received well by critics and audiences alike. The musical was praised for staying true to the film while still having its own original additions to the storyline. The score and choreography of the musical were also given praise.
The musical, however, was criticized for the length and its characters not living up to the cast of the original movie. It has also been criticized for taking the dark themes of the source material and sanitizing them with bubbly music and cartoon-like characters.
Marilyn Stasio, writing for Variety, wrote "...Seasoned industry pros could pick up a few tips on the Do's and Don'ts of adapting material from this smartly executed musical treatment of "Heathers." She praised the lyrics but was not a fan of the music, writing: "Even at their giddiest, the lyrics never dumb down the characters singing them. Wish we could say the same for the music, which is brassy and blah and sounds nothing like the music that made the 80s the 80s."
The Hollywood Reporter's David Rooney stated: "Does the acidic comedy gain anything from being turned into a cartoonish pop musical? Hell, no. But as an extension of the movie's wicked pleasures, this version has its silly charms, as demonstrated by the rowdy response of the predominantly young audience. It's not exactly very -- to borrow from Heather-speak -- but for insatiable fans it might almost be enough, and the tacky high school-style staging seems somehow appropriate."
The musical got two out of five stars from The Guardian's Alexis Soloski, who wrote: "The off-Broadway adaptation of the 1988 Winona Ryder/Christian Slater teen movie is sunny and snarky, but the dark subject matter calls for something more wicked." But Elizabeth Vincentelli of the New York Post gave it four out of fives stars, writing "The first act moves briskly as director Andy Fickman and his cast wring every last comic drop out of the script and songs... The production nearly derails in Act II, having killed off its antagonists. The film had the same problem, but here the sweetened worldview saps the grand finale of its effectiveness. Still, seeing "Heathers" onstage is a joy."
Kyle Anderson of Entertainment Weekly was harsher, giving the musical a C- rating: "Heathers: The Musical misses just about everything that made the film great, making it not only a colossally disappointing adaptation of a beloved property but also a generally unpleasant theater experience."
The London production was flagged by critics because they felt complex issues such as homosexuality, bulimia and suicide were made light of for comedic effect, making parts of the show feel "dated and uncomfortable for a 2018 audience."
|2014||Drama Desk Awards||Outstanding Music||Laurence O'Keefe and Kevin Murphy||Nominated|
|Outstanding Actress in a Musical||Barrett Wilbert Weed||Nominated|
|Lucille Lortel Award||Outstanding Lead Actress in a Musical||Nominated|
|Outstanding Choreographer||Marguerite Derricks||Nominated|
|2019||WhatsOnStage Awards||Best Actress in a Musical||Carrie Hope Fletcher||Won|
|Best Actor in a Musical||Jamie Muscato||Nominated|
|Best Supporting Actress in a Musical||Jodie Steele||Nominated|
|Best Lighting Design||Ben Cracknell||Nominated|
|Best Direction||Andy Fickman||Nominated|
|Best New Musical||Heathers: the Musical||Won|
Following its 2014 Off-Broadway run, the musical gained cult status from audiences that mirrored the characters at the fictional Westerburg High, and multiple high schools were putting in requests for the licensing rights; accordingly, an abridged "PG-13" version was prepared, newly revised by writers Laurence O'Keefe and Kevin Murphy, iTheatrics, and licensing company Samuel French specifically for student productions. Most of the profanity in the show was deleted, "Big Fun," "Dead Girl Walking," and the majority of the songs received rewritten lyrics and one new song, "You're Welcome" was written for the show to replace "Blue". The original playwrights - O'Keefe and Murphy - have since publicly stated that they prefer "You're Welcome" to "Blue", and the change was officially made for the London production of Heathers in June 2018.