Parallel (operator)
Get Parallel Operator essential facts below. View Videos or join the Parallel Operator discussion. Add Parallel Operator to your PopFlock.com topic list for future reference or share this resource on social media.
Parallel Operator

Graphical interpretation of the parallel operator with ${\displaystyle a\parallel b=c}$.

The parallel operator (also known as reduced sum, parallel sum or parallel addition${\displaystyle \|}$ (pronounced "parallel",[1] following the parallel lines notation from geometry[2][3]) is a mathematical function which is used as a shorthand in electrical engineering,[4][5][6][nb 1] but is also used in kinetics, fluid mechanics and financial mathematics.[7][8]

## Overview

The parallel operator represents the reciprocal value of a sum of reciprocal values (sometimes also referred to as "reciprocal formula") and is defined by:[9][6][10][11]

{\displaystyle {\begin{aligned}{}\parallel {}:&&{\overline {\mathbb {C} }}\times {\overline {\mathbb {C} }}&\to {\overline {\mathbb {C} }}\\&&(a,b)&\mapsto a\parallel b={\frac {1}{{\frac {1}{a}}+{\frac {1}{b}}}}={\frac {ab}{a+b}},\end{aligned}}}

with ${\displaystyle {\overline {\mathbb {C} }}=\mathbb {C} \cup \{\infty \}}$ being the extended complex numbers (with corresponding rules).[12][clarification needed] The later form is sometimes also referred to as "product over sum".

The operator gives half of the harmonic mean of two numbers a and b.[7][8]

As a special case, for ${\displaystyle a\in {\overline {\mathbb {C} }}}$:

${\displaystyle a\parallel a={\frac {a}{2}}}$.

Further, for all ${\displaystyle a,b\in {\overline {\mathbb {C} }}}$:

${\displaystyle a\neq b\iff {\big |}a\parallel b{\big |}>{\frac {1}{2}}\min(|a|,|b|)}$

with ${\displaystyle {\big |}a\parallel b{\big |}}$ representing the absolute value of ${\displaystyle a\parallel b}$.

With ${\displaystyle a}$ and ${\displaystyle b}$ being positive real numbers follows ${\displaystyle {\big |}a\parallel b{\big |}<\min(a,b)}$.

The concept has been extended from a scalar operation to matrices[13][14][15][16][17] and further generalized.[18]

## Notation

The operator was originally introduced as reduced sum by Sundaram Seshu in 1956,[19][20][13] studied as operator * by Kent E. Erickson in 1959,[21][22][13] and popularized by Richard James Duffin and William Niles Anderson, Jr. as parallel addition or parallel sum operator : in mathematics and network theory since 1966.[14][15][1] While some authors continue to use this symbol up to the present,[7][8] for example, Sujit Kumar Mitra used ? as a symbol in 1970.[13] In applied electronics, a ? sign became more common as the operator's symbol later on.[23][24][25][26][nb 1][nb 2] This was often written as doubled vertical line (||) available in most character sets, but now can be represented using Unicode character U+2225 ( ? ) for "parallel to". In LaTeX and related markup languages, the macros \| and \parallel are often used to denote the operator's symbol.

## Rules

For addition, the parallel operator follows the commutative law:

${\displaystyle a\parallel b=b\parallel a}$

and the associative law:[12][7][8]

${\displaystyle (a\parallel b)\parallel c=a\parallel (b\parallel c)=a\parallel b\parallel c={\frac {1}{{\frac {1}{a}}+{\frac {1}{b}}+{\frac {1}{c}}}}={\frac {abc}{ab+ac+bc}}}$

Multiplication is distributive over this operation.[1][7][8]

Further, the parallel operator has ${\displaystyle \infty }$ as neutral element and, for ${\displaystyle a\in {\overline {\mathbb {C} }}\setminus \{0\},}$ the number ${\displaystyle -a}$ as inverse element. However, ${\displaystyle \left({\overline {\mathbb {C} }},\parallel \right)}$ is not an abelian group, as ${\displaystyle a\parallel 0=0}$ for every nonzero a, and ${\displaystyle 0\parallel 0}$ is not well defined (indeterminate form).

In the absence of parentheses, the parallel operator is defined as taking precedence over addition or subtraction.[1][27][9][10]

## Applications

In electrical engineering, the parallel operator can be used to calculate the total impedance of various serial and parallel electrical circuits.[nb 2]

For instance, the total resistance of resistors connected in parallel is the reciprocal of the sum of the reciprocals of the individual resistors.

${\displaystyle {\frac {1}{R_{\text{eq}}}}={\frac {1}{R_{1}}}+{\frac {1}{R_{2}}}+\cdots +{\frac {1}{R_{n}}}}$.

Likewise for the total capacitance of serial capacitors.[nb 2]

The same principle can be applied to various problems in other disciplines.

There is a duality between the usual (series) sum and the parallel sum.[7][8]

## Examples

Question:

Three resistors ${\displaystyle R_{1}=270\,\mathrm {k\Omega } }$, ${\displaystyle R_{2}=180\,\mathrm {k\Omega } }$ and ${\displaystyle R_{3}=120\,\mathrm {k\Omega } }$ are connected in parallel. What is their resulting resistance?

${\displaystyle R_{1}\parallel R_{2}\parallel R_{3}=270\,\mathrm {k\Omega } \parallel 180\,\mathrm {k\Omega } \parallel 120\,\mathrm {k\Omega } ={\frac {1}{{\frac {1}{270\,\mathrm {k\Omega } }}+{\frac {1}{180\,\mathrm {k\Omega } }}+{\frac {1}{120\,\mathrm {k\Omega } }}}}\approx 56.84\,\mathrm {k\Omega } }$
The effectively resulting resistance is ca. 57 kΩ.

Question:[7][8]

A construction worker raises a wall in 5 hours. Another worker would need 7 hours for the same work. How long does it take to build the wall if both worker work in parallel?

${\displaystyle t_{1}\parallel t_{2}=5\,\mathrm {h} \parallel 7\,\mathrm {h} ={\frac {1}{{\frac {1}{5\,\mathrm {h} }}+{\frac {1}{7\,\mathrm {h} }}}}\approx 2.92\,\mathrm {h} }$
They will finish in close to 3 hours.

## Implementation

WP 34S with parallel operator (?) on the + key.

Suggested already by Kent E. Erickson as a subroutine in digital computers in 1959,[21] the parallel operator is implemented as a keyboard operator on the Reverse Polish Notation (RPN) scientific calculators WP 34S since 2008[28][29][30] as well as on the WP 34C[31] and WP 43S since 2015,[32][33] allowing to solve even cascaded problems with few keystrokes like .

## Notes

1. ^ a b While the use of the symbol ? for "parallel" in geometry reaches as far back as 1673 in John Kersey the elder's work,[A] this came into more use only since about 1875.[B] The usage of a mathematical operator for parallel circuits originates from network theory in electrical engineering. Sundaram Seshu introduced a reduced sum operator in 1956,[C] Kent E. Erickson proposed an asterisk (*) to symbolize the operator in 1959,[D] whilst Richard James Duffin and William Niles Anderson, Jr. used a colon (:) for the parallel addition since 1966.[E] Sujit Kumar Mitra used a middot (?) for it in 1970.[F] The first usage of the parallel symbol (?) for this operator in applied electronics is unknown, but might have originated from John W. McWane's 1981 book "Introduction to Electronics and Instrumentation",[G] which grew out of an identically-named MIT course developed as part of its influential Technical Curriculum Development Project between 1974 and 1979. This symbol was probably also introduced because the other used symbols could be easily confused with signs commonly used for multiplication and division in some contexts.
2. ^ a b c In electrical circuits the parallel operator can be applied to, respectively, parallel resistances (R in [?]) or inductances (L in [H]) as well as to impedances (Z in [?]) or reactances (X in [?]). Ignoring the operator symbol's then-misleading glyph it can also be applied to series circuits of, respectively, conductances (G in [S]) or capacitances (C in [F]) as well as to admittances (Y in [S]) or susceptances (B in [S]).

## References

1. ^ a b c d Duffin, Richard James (1971) [1970, 1969]. "Network Models". Written at Durham, North Carolina, USA. In Wilf, Herbert Saul; Hararay, Frank (eds.). Mathematical Aspects of Electrical Network Analysis. Proceedings of a Symposium in Applied Mathematics of the American Mathematical Society and the Society for Industrial and Applied Mathematics held in New York City, 1969-04-02/03. Volume III of SIAM-AMS Proceedings (illustrated ed.). Providence, Rhode Island: American Mathematical Society (AMS) / Society for Industrial and Applied Mathematics (SIAM). pp. 65-92 [68]. ISBN 0-8218-1322-6. ISSN 0080-5084. LCCN 79-167683. ISBN 978-0-8218-1322-5. Report 69-21. Retrieved . pp. 68-69: [...] To have a convenient short notation for the joint resistance of resistors connected in parallel let [...] A:B = AB/(A+B) [...] A:B may be regarded as a new operation termed parallel addition [...] Parallel addition is defined for any nonnegative numbers. The network model shows that parallel addition is commutative and associative. Moreover, multiplication is distributive over this operation. Consider now an algebraic expression in the operations (+) and (:) operating on positive numbers A, B, C, etc. [...] To give a network interpretation of such a polynomial read A + B as "A series B" and A : B as "A parallel B" then it is clear that the expression [...] is the joint resistance of the network [...] [1] [2] (206 pages)
2. ^ Kersey (the elder), John (1673). "Chapter I: Concerning the Scope of this fourth Book and the Signification of Characters, Abbreviations and Citations used therein". The Elements of that Mathematical Art, commonly called Algebra. Book IV - The Elements of the Algebraical Arts. London: Thomas Passinger, Three-Bibles, London-Bridge. pp. 177-178. Archived from the original on 2020-08-05. Retrieved .
3. ^ Cajori, Florian (1993) [September 1928]. "§ 184, § 359, § 368". A History of Mathematical Notations - Notations in Elementary Mathematics. 1 (two volumes in one unaltered reprint ed.). Chicago, US: Open court publishing company. pp. 193, 402-403, 411-412. ISBN 0-486-67766-4. LCCN 93-29211. Retrieved . pp. 402-403, 411-412: §359. [...] ? for parallel occurs in Oughtred's Opuscula mathematica hactenus inedita (1677) [p. 197], a posthumous work (§ 184) [...] §368. Signs for parallel lines. [...] when Recorde's sign of equality won its way upon the Continent, vertical lines came to be used for parallelism. We find ? for "parallel" in Kersey,[A]Caswell, Jones,[B] Wilson,[C]Emerson,[D] Kambly,[E] and the writers of the last fifty years who have been already quoted in connection with other pictographs. Before about 1875 it does not occur as often [...] Hall and Stevens[F] use "par[F] or ?" for parallel [...] [A] John Kersey, Algebra (London, 1673), Book IV, p. 177. [B] W. Jones, Synopsis palmarioum matheseos (London, 1706). [C] John Wilson, Trigonometry (Edinburgh, 1714), characters explained. [D] W. Emerson, Elements of Geometry (London, 1763), p. 4. [E] L. Kambly [de], Die Elementar-Mathematik, Part 2: Planimetrie, 43. edition (Breslau, 1876), p. 8. [...] [F] H. S. Hall and F. H. Stevens, Euclid's Elements, Parts I and II (London, 1889), p. 10. [...] [3]
4. ^ "INA 326/INA 327 - Precision, Rail-to-Rail I/O Instrumentation Amplifier" (PDF). Burr-Brown / Texas Instruments. 2018 [November 2004, November 2001]. pp. 3, 9, 13. SBOS222D. Archived (PDF) from the original on 2019-07-13. Retrieved .
5. ^ Bober, William; Stevens, Andrew (2016). "Chapter 7.6. Laplace Transforms Applied to Circuits". Numerical and Analytical Methods with MATLAB for Electrical Engineers. Applied and Computational Mechanics (1 ed.). CRC Press. p. 224. ISBN 978-1-46657607-0. ISBN 1-46657607-3. (388 pages)
6. ^ a b Ranade, Gireeja; Stojanovic, Vladimir, eds. (Fall 2018). "Chapter 15.7.2 Parallel Resistors" (PDF). EECS 16A Designing Information Devices and Systems I (PDF) (lecture notes). University of California, Berkeley. p. 12. Note 15. Archived (PDF) from the original on 2018-12-27. Retrieved . p. 12: [...] This mathematical relationship comes up often enough that it actually has a name: the "parallel operator", denoted ?. When we say x?y, it means ${\displaystyle {\frac {xy}{x+y}}}$. Note that this is a mathematical operator and does not say anything about the actual configuration. In the case of resistors the parallel operator is used for parallel resistors, but for other components (like capacitors) this is not the case. [...] (16 pages)
7. Ellerman, David Patterson (1995-03-21). "Chapter 12: Parallel Addition, Series-Parallel Duality, and Financial Mathematics". Intellectual Trespassing as a Way of Life: Essays in Philosophy, Economics, and Mathematics (PDF). The worldly philosophy: studies in intersection of philosophy and economics. G - Reference, Information and Interdisciplinary Subjects Series (illustrated ed.). Rowman & Littlefield Publishers, Inc. pp. 237-268. ISBN 0-8476-7932-2. Archived (PDF) from the original on 2016-03-05. Retrieved . p. 237: [...] When resistors with resistance a and b are placed in series, their compound resistance is the usual sum (hereafter the series sum) of the resistances a + b. If the resistances are placed in parallel, their compound resistance is the parallel sum of the resistances, which is denoted by the full colon [...] [4] (271 pages)
8. Ellerman, David Patterson (May 2004) [1995-03-21]. "Introduction to Series-Parallel Duality" (PDF). University of California at Riverside. CiteSeerX 10.1.1.90.3666. Archived from the original on 2019-08-10. Retrieved . The parallel sum of two positive real numbers x:y = [(1/x) + (1/y)]-1 arises in electrical circuit theory as the resistance resulting from hooking two resistances x and y in parallel. There is a duality between the usual (series) sum and the parallel sum. [...] [5] (24 pages)
9. ^ a b Basso, Christophe P. (2016). "Chapter 1.1.2 The Current Divider". Linear Circuit Transfer Functions: An Introduction to Fast Analytical Techniques (1 ed.). Chichester, West Sussex, New Jersey, USA: John Wiley & Sons Ltd. p. 12. ISBN 978-1-11923637-5. LCCN 2015047967. Retrieved . (464 pages)
10. ^ a b Cotter, Neil E., ed. (2015-10-12) [2014-09-20]. "ECE1250 Cookbook - Nodes, Series, Parallel" (lecture notes). Cookbooks. University of Utah. Archived (PDF) from the original on 2020-08-20. Retrieved . [...] One convenient way to indicate two resistors are in parallel is to put a ? between them. [...]
11. ^ Böcker, Joachim (2019-03-18) [April 2008]. "Grundlagen der Elektrotechnik Teil B" (PDF) (in German). Universität Paderborn. p. 12. Archived (PDF) from the original on 2018-04-17. Retrieved . p. 12: Für die Berechnung des Ersatzwiderstands der Parallelschaltung wird [...] gern die Kurzschreibweise ? benutzt.
12. ^ a b Georg, Otfried (2013) [1999]. "Chapter 2.11.4.3: Aufstellen der Differentialgleichung aus der komplexen Darstellung - MATHCAD Anwendung 2.11-6: Benutzerdefinierte Operatoren". Elektromagnetische Felder und Netzwerke: Anwendungen in Mathcad und PSpice. Springer-Lehrbuch (in German) (1 ed.). Springer-Verlag. pp. 246-248. doi:10.1007/978-3-642-58420-6. ISBN 978-3-642-58420-6. ISBN 3-642-58420-9. Retrieved . (728 pages)
13. ^ a b c d Mitra, Sujit Kumar (February 1970). "A Matrix Operation for Analyzing Series-parallel Multiports". Journal of the Franklin Institute. Brief Communication. Franklin Institute. 289 (2): 167-169. doi:10.1016/0016-0032(70)90302-9. p. 167: The purpose of this communication is to extend the concept of the scalar operation Reduced Sum introduced by Seshu [...] and later elaborated by Erickson [...] to matrices, to outline some interesting properties of this new matrix operation, and to apply the matrix operation in the analysis of series and parallel n-port networks. Let A and B be two non-singular square matrices having inverses, A-1 and B-1 respectively. We define the operation ? as A ? B = (A-1 + B-1)-1 and the operation ? as A ? B = A ? (-B). The operation ? is commutative and associative and is also distributive with respect to multiplication. [...] (3 pages)
14. ^ a b Duffin, Richard James; Hazony, Dov; Morrison, Norman Alexander (March 1966) [1965-04-12, 1964-08-25]. "Network synthesis through hybrid matrices". SIAM Journal on Applied Mathematics. Society for Industrial and Applied Mathematics (SIAM). 14 (2): 390-413. doi:10.1137/0114032. JSTOR 2946272. (24 pages)
15. ^ a b Anderson, Jr., William Niles; Duffin, Richard James (1969) [1968-05-27]. "Series and parallel addition of matrices". Journal of Mathematical Analysis and Applications. Academic Press, Inc. 26 (3): 576-594. doi:10.1016/0022-247X(69)90200-5. p. 576: [...] we define the parallel sum of A and B by the formula A(A + B)+B and denote it by A : B. If A and B are nonsingular this reduces to A : B = (A-1 + B-1)-1 which is the well known electrical formula for addition of resistors in parallel. Then it is shown that the Hermitian semi-definite matrices form a commutative partially ordered semigroup under the parallel sum operation. [...] [6]
16. ^ Mitra, Sujit Kumar; Puri, Madan Lal (October 1973). "On Parallel Sum and Difference of Matrices" (PDF). Journal of Mathematical Analysis and Applications. Academic Press, Inc. 44 (1): 92-97. doi:10.1016/0022-247X(73)90027-9. Archived from the original (PDF) on 2019-04-13.
17. ^ Mitra, Sujit Kumar; Bhimasankaram, Pochiraju; Malik, Saroj B. (2010). Matrix Partial Orders, Shorted Operators and Applications. Series in Algebra. 10 (illustrated 1st ed.). World Scientific Publishing Co. Pte. Ltd. ISBN 978-981-283-844-5. ISBN 981-283-844-9. Retrieved . (446 pages)
18. ^ Eriksson-Bique, Sirkka-Liisa Anneli; Leutwiler, Heinz (February 1989) [1989-01-10]. "A generalization of parallel addition" (PDF). Aequationes Mathematicae. Birkhäuser Verlag. 38 (1): 99-110. doi:10.1007/BF01839498. Archived (PDF) from the original on 2020-08-20. Retrieved .
19. ^ Seshu, Sundaram (September 1956). "On Electrical Circuits and Switching Circuits". IRE Transactions on Circuit Theory. Institute of Radio Engineers (IRE). CT-3 (3): 172-178. doi:10.1109/TCT.1956.1086310. (7 pages) (NB. See errata.)
20. ^ Seshu, Sundaram; Gould, Roderick (September 1957). "Correction to 'On Electrical Circuits and Switching Circuits'". IRE Transactions on Circuit Theory. Correction. Institute of Radio Engineers (IRE). CT-4 (3): 284. doi:10.1109/TCT.1957.1086390. (1 page) (NB. Refers to previous reference.)
21. ^ a b Erickson, Kent E. (March 1959). "A New Operation for Analyzing Series-Parallel Networks". IRE Transactions on Circuit Theory. Institute of Radio Engineers (IRE). CT-6 (1): 124-126. doi:10.1109/TCT.1959.1086519. p. 124: [...] The operation * is defined as A * B = AB/A + B. The symbol * has algebraic properties which simplify the formal solution of many series-parallel network problems. If the operation * were included as a subroutine in a digital computer, it could simplify the programming of certain network calculations. [...] (3 pages) (NB. See comment.)
22. ^ Kaufman, Howard (June 1963). "Remark on a New Operation for Analyzing Series-Parallel Networks". IEEE Transactions on Circuit Theory. Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE). CT-10 (2): 283. doi:10.1109/TCT.1963.1082126. p. 283: [...] Comments on the operation * [...] a*b = ab/(a+b) [...] (1 page) (NB. Refers to previous reference.)
23. ^ Wolf, Lawrence J. (1977) [1976, 1974]. "Section 4. Instructional Materials - 4.3. The MIT Technical Curriculum Development Project - Introduction to Electronics and Instrumentation". In Aldridge, Bill G.; Mowery, Donald R.; Wolf, Lawrence J.; Dixon, Peggy (eds.). Science and Engineering Technology - Curriculum Guide: A Guide to a Two-Year Associate Degree Curriculum (PDF). Saint Louis Community College-Florissant Valley, St. Louis, Missouri, USA: National Science Teachers Association, Washington DC, USA. pp. 21, 77. Archived (PDF) from the original on 2017-02-15. Retrieved . p. 21: [...] Introduction to Electronics and Instrumentation is a new and contemporary approach to the introductory electronics course. Designed for students with no prior experience with electronics, it develops the skills and knowledge necessary to use and understand modern electronic systems. [...] John W. McWane [...] (NB. The SET Project was a two-year post-secondary curriculum developed between 1974 and 1977 preparing technicians to use electronic instruments.)
24. ^ Wiesner, Jerome Bert; Johnson, Howard Wesley; Killian, Jr., James Rhyne, eds. (1978-04-11). "School of Engineering - Center for Advanced Engineering Study (C.A.E.S.) - Research and Development - Technical Curriculum Research and Development Project". Report of the President and the Chancellor 1977-78 - Massachusetts Institute of Technology (PDF). Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT). pp. 249, 252-253. Archived (PDF) from the original on 2015-09-10. Retrieved . pp. 249, 252-253: [...] The Technical Curriculum Research and Development Program, sponsored by the Imperial Organization of Social Services of Iran, is entering the fourth year of a five-year contract. Curriculum development in electronics and mechanical engineering continues. [...] Administered jointly by C.A.E.S. and the Department of Materials Science and Engineering, the Project is under the supervision of Professor Merton C. Flemings. It is directed by Dr. John W. McWane. [...] Curriculum Materials Development. This is the principal activity of the project and is concerned with the development of innovative, state-of-the-art course materials in needed areas of engineering technology [...] new introductory course in electronics [...] is entitled Introduction to Electronics and Instrumentation and consists of eight [...] modules [...] dc Current, Voltage, and Resistance; Basic Circuit Networks; Time Varying Signals; Operational Amplifiers; Power Supplies; ac Current, Voltage, and Impedance; Digital Circuits; and Electronic Measurement and Control. This course represents a major change and updating of the way in which electronics is introduced, and should be of great value to STI as well as to many US programs. [...]
25. ^ Wedlock, Bruce D. (1978). Basic circuit networks. Technical Curriculum Research and Development Project. Introduction to electronics and instrumentation. Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT). (81 pages) (NB. This formed the basis for Part I of McWane's 1981 book.)
26. ^ McWane, John W. (1981-05-01). Introduction to Electronics and Instrumentation (illustrated ed.). North Scituate, Massachusetts, USA: Breton Publishers, Wadsworth, Inc. pp. 78, 96-98, 100, 104. ISBN 0-53400938-7. ISBN 978-0-53400938-0. Retrieved . p. xiii, 96-98, 100: [...] Bruce D. Wedlock [...] was the principle contributing author to Part I, BASIC CIRCUIT NETWORKS including the design of the companion examples. [...] Most of the development of the IEI program was undertaken as part of the Technical Curriculum Research and Development Project of the MIT Center of Advanced Engineering Study. [...] shorthand notation [...] shorthand symbol ? [...] (xiii+545 pages) (NB. In 1981, a 216-pages laboratory manual accompanying this book existed as well. The work grew out of an MIT course program "The MIT Technical Curriculum Development Project - Introduction to Electronics and Instrumentation" developed between 1974 and 1979. In 1986, a second edition of this book was published under the title "Introduction to Electronics Technology".)
27. ^ Paul, Steffen; Paul, Reinhold (2014-10-24). "Chapter 2.3.2: Zusammenschaltungen linearer resistiver Zweipole - Parallelschaltung". Grundlagen der Elektrotechnik und Elektronik 1: Gleichstromnetzwerke und ihre Anwendungen (in German). 1 (5 ed.). Springer-Verlag. p. 78. ISBN 978-3-64253948-0. ISBN 3-64253948-3. Retrieved . p. 78: [...] Bei abgekürzter Schreibweise achte man sorgfältig auf die Anwendung von Klammern. [...] Das Parallelzeichen ? der Kurzschreibweise hat die gleiche Bedeutung wie ein Multiplikationszeichen. Deshalb können Klammern entfallen. (446 pages)
28. ^ Dale, Paul; Bonin, Walter (2012-11-30) [2008-12-09]. WP 34S Owner's Manual (PDF) (3.1 ed.). pp. 1, 14, 32, 66, 116. Archived (PDF) from the original on 2019-07-09. Retrieved . [7] (211 pages)
29. ^ Bonin, Walter (2015) [2008-12-09]. WP 34S Owner's Manual (3.3 ed.). CreateSpace Independent Publishing Platform. ISBN 978-1-5078-9107-0. [8]
30. ^ Bonin, Walter (2016-07-11) [2008-12-09]. WP 34S Owner's Manual (4 ed.). CreateSpace Independent Publishing Platform. ISBN 978-1-53366238-5. ISBN 1-53366238-X. (410 pages)
31. ^ Dowrick, Nigel (2015-05-03) [2015-03-16]. "Complex Lock mode for WP-34s". HP Museum. Archived from the original on 2019-04-03. Retrieved .
32. ^ Bonin, Walter (2020) [2015]. WP 43S Owner's Manual (PDF). 0.16 (draft ed.). p. 119. ISBN 978-1-72950098-9. ISBN 1-72950098-6. Retrieved . [9] [10] (328 pages)
33. ^ Bonin, Walter (2020) [2015]. WP 43S Reference Manual (PDF). 0.16 (draft ed.). p. 127. ISBN 978-1-72950106-1. ISBN 1-72950106-0. Retrieved . [11] [12] (315 pages)